Compare vacation rentals in Fire Island, NY from 100+ sites!

About: Shores Retreat is a private suite situated in a peaceful cul-de-sac adjacent to a wooded area with access to a stream for kayaking and canoeing. It's conveniently located between New York City and the Hamptons, making it an ideal base for exploring both destinations. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this accommodation offers a charming bedroom with a queen-size bed, a cozy living room with a 55-inch flat-screen TV and gas fireplace, and a private bathroom with a walk-in shower. Guests can enjoy the use of outdoor spaces, including a large deck, hot tub, fire pit, hammock, and swing, as well as amenities like free Wi-Fi, a refrigerator, microwave, and coffee bar.

About: Accommodation for up to 4 people with an excellent rating of 98% based on 286 reviews. You will be based in Bay Shore.

Services and facilities: free parking, air conditioning and an iron.

About:

About:

About: House for up to 8 guests with an excellent rating of 85% based on 81 reviews. You will stay in Fire Island.

Services and facilities include a dish washer, a garden and a tennis court.

About: This waterfront condo on Fire Island is steps from Ocean Beach and a short drive from Sunken Forest and Sailors' Haven. It has received very good ratings for its location and overall experience.

The apartment features a private patio, a fully equipped kitchen, a sofa bed for extra sleeping space, air conditioning, a swimming pool, a garden, parking, and allows pets. Guests can enjoy waterfront views of the Great South Bay, relax on the patio, or take advantage of the many amenities and activities available nearby.

About: Apartment rental for 4 people with an excellent rating of 99% based on 31 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Fire Island.

Services and facilities: air conditioning, a terrace and a kitchen. Take advantage of the gym in this apartment in Fire Island.

About: This North Bay Shore apartment is situated near Brentwood State Park, offering stunning coastal views and easy access to outdoor recreation, shopping, and entertainment. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and user experience.

The apartment features a cozy fireplace, a fully equipped kitchen, a separate dining area, air conditioning, a terrace/balcony, a garden, parking, and allows pets. It has one bathroom and a check-out time of 10:00 AM.

About: This waterfront vacation home is located in Mastic Beach, 1.6 miles from William Floyd Estate and 2.6 miles from Carmans River. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and amenities.

The house has a floor area of 1800 square feet and can accommodate up to 6 guests. It has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, a fully equipped kitchen, a patio, and a garden. The house also has a private dock, a barbecue grill, and a washing machine.

About: This waterfront designer beach house offers a unique and luxurious getaway in Mastic Beach, facing Fire Island, with Smith Point Park Beach 10 minutes away and a 90-minute drive from New York City. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and user experience.

The accommodation features 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a guest capacity of 6. It boasts high-end appliances and amenities, including a washer and dryer, a spacious pop-art loft space for family activities, and a private beach with a boat mooring area. The Art Deco-inspired design with unique interior design touches adds to the charm of this waterfront retreat.

About: This cozy cottage is nestled in Shirley, a block from the local beach and playground, and a 2-minute drive to Smith Point Beach. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this accommodation is a great choice for travelers.

The cottage features three bedrooms, one bathroom, and a spacious outdoor area with a fenced-in yard. It can accommodate up to four guests and includes amenities such as Wi-Fi, cable, washer/dryer, four bicycles, and all bills are included in the rental price.

About: This cozy 3-bedroom apartment is situated in a quiet, family-friendly neighborhood in Ocean Bay Park, just one block from the beach. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. The apartment can accommodate up to 6 guests and includes a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious deck with a grill and beach equipment, and bikes for exploring the island.

In addition to the proximity to the beach and family-friendly amenities, the apartment also features a fireplace in the living room, a washer/dryer, and WiFi. It is an ideal choice for families seeking a peaceful and relaxing vacation on Fire Island.

About: This Bayport apartment is located a 7-minute walk from a sandy beach, 5 minutes from two Fire Island Ferry terminals, and between two ferry terminals, providing easy access to Fire Island. It has excellent user ratings and can accommodate up to 8 guests in its 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, with a floor area of 2100 square feet.

The apartment features a variety of amenities, including a swimming pool, a Jacuzzi, a sauna, a spa, and a garden. It also has a kitchen with a fridge, a microwave oven, and a dishwasher, as well as air conditioning, internet, a terrace or balcony, and parking.

About: Brushwood House by Smith Point Beach is a luxurious four-bedroom, two-bathroom country house situated in Shirley, 18 miles from Splish Splash and 24 miles from Long Island Railroad. It offers a private beach area and air conditioning. The house has an excellent user rating and a very good cleanliness rating.

The house has a floor area of 4970 square feet and features a fully equipped kitchen, a private pool, outdoor play equipment, a picnic area, a sun terrace, and free Wi-Fi. Guests can also enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast each morning. The house also offers a paid airport shuttle service for convenient transportation to and from Long Island MacArthur Airport.

About: This charming 1930s brick house is located in East Patchogue, offering stunning bay views and a peaceful retreat just steps from the water's edge. It is close to landmarks like the Fire Island National Seashore, Heckscher State Park, and the Patchogue Theatre, and it has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings.

The house has 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, and can accommodate up to 6 guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a spacious backyard, a private pool, and access to waterfront activities like swimming, kayaking, and fishing.

About: Cottage for 6 guests with an excellent rating of 98% based on 20 reviews. You will be in Bellport.

Facilities and services include a garden, a washing machine and a barbecue.

About: Apartment for up to 7 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 4 reviews. This accommodation is based in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: a washing machine, a fridge and a barbecue. This apartment in Fire Island has a swimming pool!

About:

About: This vacation home in East Patchogue is just 1.1 miles from Great South Bay and within 3 miles of Long Island Community Hospital and Brookhaven Memorial Hospital Medical Center. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings.

The house has a spacious 4-bedroom layout and is fully equipped with a kitchen, free WiFi, air conditioning, a private outdoor pool, a fenced private yard, a garden, a fitness center, parking, and barbecue grills.

About: Apartment rental for 6 people with an excellent rating of 100% based on 9 reviews. You will stay in Fire Island.

Services and facilities include a barbecue, a fridge and a terrace.

About: Enjoy a relaxing stay in this highly-rated vacation home by the beach in East Patchogue, New York. The house includes 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and can accommodate up to 6 guests, making it ideal for families or groups.

This charming house features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a terrace, a garden, parking, and even an arcade/game room for entertainment. It's also conveniently located near popular tourist attractions like Carmans River and Fire Island National Seashore.

About: This waterfront cottage in Center Moriches, New York, offers a unique and memorable vacation experience. Situated 15 minutes from the Hamptons, it provides easy access to popular attractions like Splish Splash, Riverhead Aquarium, and Tanger Mall. With an excellent user rating, this cottage guarantees a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

The cottage boasts a spacious 1300 square feet of living space with 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a loft for additional sleeping, accommodating up to 6 guests. Its fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, and automated surround sound and TV system ensure a comfortable and entertaining stay. The cottage's private dock and waterfront location on Senix Creek Canal offer opportunities for boating, kayaking, and paddle boarding, while the spacious yard with a putting green and basketball court provides ample outdoor entertainment.

About: Ocean Beach's Type: Island is a family-friendly vacation home with a user rating of excellent. It is within walking distance of the beach and a short drive from the town center.

The island has 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a guest capacity of 8. It features a screened-in front porch, rooftop deck with lounge chairs and dining area, and an enclosed outdoor shower. The home also includes amenities such as a kitchen with a fridge, microwave oven, and dishwasher, air conditioning, and high-speed Fios Wi-Fi.

About: Sandy Toes bungalow is a quiet and private retreat at a 5-minute walk from the ferry dock in Ocean Beach. The bungalow has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings. It has 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and a guest capacity of 6.

The bungalow provides comfort and amenities such as a large deck, an outdoor shower, plush mattresses, crisp linens, Direct TV, Wi-Fi, air conditioning, a fully stocked kitchen, wine and cheese platter upon arrival, bicycles, wagons/carts, and beach chairs.

About: Apartment rental for up to 8 guests with an excellent rating of 96% based on 39 reviews. Your accommodation will be located in Fire Island.

Services and facilities: air conditioning, a freeze and a kitchen. Take advantage of the garden in this apartment in Fire Island.

About: This golf vacation home in Bellport is centrally located, within 3 miles of Great South Bay and 6 miles of Patchogue Theatre for the Performing Arts. It has excellent user ratings and is family-friendly.

The house has 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a sofa bed, accommodating up to 5 guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, air conditioning, a garden, and parking. Guests can enjoy outdoor amenities like barbecue grills and a fenced private yard.

About: Vacation rental listing for 8 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 3 reviews. You will be based in Fire Island.

Facilities and services: an iron, a freeze and a terrace. Take advantage of the air conditioning in this house in Fire Island.

About: Accommodation for 6 guests with an excellent rating of 99% based on 45 reviews. You will be in Mastic Beach.

Services and facilities: free parking, a barbecue and a garden. This is a pet-friendly accommodation!

About: This private studio in Fire Island Pines offers a secluded retreat just steps from the harbor and beach. It has received excellent ratings for its location, cleanliness, and user experience.

The studio features a kitchenette with a dishwasher, a dining table for two, an oversized bathroom, and an outdoor shower. It accommodates up to two guests in two twin XL beds and has a strict maximum of two guests policy to ensure privacy.

About: This Islip Terrace apartment is situated by the sea, offering scenic views from its balcony. It is within 2 miles of major attractions like Cohalan Court Complex and Bethpage Ballpark. With excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings, this apartment is a top choice for travelers.

The apartment features a 400-square-foot layout with one bedroom, one bathroom, and a sofa bed for additional sleeping space. Guests can enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, free WiFi, air conditioning, and access to a garden with barbecue grills. The smoke-free environment ensures a comfortable stay for all guests.

About: This apartment is located in Fire Island, a 5-minute walk from Ho-Hum Beach. It has excellent location and cleanliness ratings. It has 1 bedroom, 1 bathroom, and can accommodate up to 4 guests. It has amenities such as a fully equipped kitchen, private patio, air conditioning, fitness center, and free WiFi.

About: This cottage is located near the beach in Bellport, within walking distance of Bellport Station, and 6 miles from Brookhaven Memorial Hospital Medical Center and Monster Mini Golf. It has excellent user, location, and cleanliness ratings.

The cottage has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom and can accommodate up to 6 guests. It features a fully equipped kitchen, a comfortable living area with a TV and a patio, a garden with barbecue grills, air conditioning, a terrace or balcony, a Jacuzzi, and parking.

About: