Search vacation rental in Shelter Island, NY from 100+ sites!

This apartment is located in a peaceful neighborhood in Wainscott, just a few minutes away from the bustling East Hampton Village. With excellent user, location and cleanliness ratings, this property is a great choice for travelers seeking a comfortable and convenient stay.
This private and spacious home can accommodate up to 6 guests in its 3 bedrooms. It offers a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge, microwave oven and dishwasher, air conditioning, a garden, and parking. Guests can enjoy nearby activities such as visiting East Hampton Village, exploring local beaches, and shopping at the many boutiques and art galleries in the area.

Book this vacation rental for 8 guests with an excellent rating of 98% based on 40 reviews. You will be in Noyack.
Services and facilities: an iron, a kitchen and a barbecue. Take advantage of the Free Parking with this accommodation.

Vacation rental listing for up to 12 guests with an excellent rating of 99% based on 14 reviews. Your accommodation will be located in Noyack.
Facilities and services include a swimming pool, a washing machine and free parking. This apartment in Noyack also has a garden!

Apartment listing for 10 guests with an excellent rating of 97% based on 32 reviews. You will be located in Noyack.
Services and facilities include a garden, a fridge and a coffee place. This is a pet-friendly apartment!

Vacation rental listing for up to 6 guests with an excellent rating of 98% based on 79 reviews. This accommodation is based in Greenport.
Facilities and services: a washing machine, a kitchen and a barbecue. This apartment also has air conditioning!

Cottage rental for up to 7 people with an excellent rating of 99% based on 32 reviews. Your accommodation will be based in Shelter Island.
Facilities and services: a freeze, an iron and a dish washer. You can bring your favorite pets this accommodation!

House from 1972 dollars per night for up to 9 people. You will be based in Noyack.
Facilities and services: a terrace, a kitchen and air conditioning.

Book this vacation rental for 8 people. Your accommodation will be based in Noyack.
Facilities and services: a freeze, a ping pong table and a kitchen. Take advantage of the air conditioning in this apartment in Noyack.

Yacht for up to 12 people with an excellent rating of 100% based on 2 reviews. You will be located in Sag Harbor.
Services and facilities include free parking, a kitchen and a swimming pool. Take advantage of the garden in this accommodation!

Apartment to rent for up to 6 guests with an excellent rating of 100% based on 4 reviews. This accommodation is based in Noyack.
Services and facilities include a freeze, a kitchen and free parking. Enjoy a swimming pool in this apartment in Noyack!

In the heart of Water Mill, this family-friendly house is ideally located near the beach, restaurants, and shops.
With 2200 square feet of living space, this house offers 1 bathroom and a fully equipped kitchen with a fridge.
Guests can enjoy air conditioning, a swimming pool, and parking. Nearby activities include swimming, sunbathing, and exploring the charming town of Water Mill.

Boat rental for 6 people. Your accommodation will be based in Sag Harbor.
Services and facilities: a fridge, an iron and a freeze.

Vacation house rental for up to 6 people. You will be based in Sag Harbor.
Services and facilities include a washing machine, a dish washer and a kitchen. This house in Sag Harbor also has air conditioning!